天美传媒

Skip to content
Society & Culture

After Maduro鈥檚 capture, what comes next for Venezuela?

RED FLAG? The Venezuelan military in a show of support for leader Nicol谩s Maduro in November 2025. 鈥淭he military propped up Maduro,鈥� explains 天美传媒 political scientist Hein Goemans. 鈥淭here鈥檚 no reason to believe that they鈥檙e now suddenly going to give up power.鈥� (Getty Images photo)

A 天美传媒 expert on international conflict warns that regime change rarely brings stability.

The US seizure of Venezuelan leader Nicol谩s Maduro stunned people around the world鈥攊ncluding political scientists who study regime change.

鈥淚 was surprised,鈥� says , professor of and director of the at the 天美传媒. 鈥淕oing in the middle of the night, taking the leader of the country and his wife out of the palace, and saying, 鈥楾hat鈥檚 it, we鈥檙e running the country now.鈥� That鈥檚 extraordinary.鈥�

For many Venezuelans, particularly those who fled repression and economic collapse, the news sparked celebration and hope. But Goemans urges caution, arguing that removing a dictator rarely dismantles the power structures that kept him in place.

The Venezuelan military still holds power

鈥淭he military propped up Maduro,鈥� Goemans says. 鈥淭he whole system of bribery and corruption revolves around the support of the armed forces. There鈥檚 no reason to believe that they鈥檙e now suddenly going to give up power.鈥�

鈥�Post鈥搑egime change almost never works the way people hope.鈥�

He compares the situation to previous US-led interventions.

鈥淲e鈥檝e seen this in Iraq, we鈥檝e seen it in Afghanistan,鈥� Goemans says. 鈥淒ecapitation鈥攖aking out one leader鈥攄oesn鈥檛 change the apparatus of the state. Post鈥搑egime change almost never works the way people hope.鈥�

Goemans points to research by political scientist showing that foreign-imposed regime change frequently leads to instability or renewed conflict, not democracy. 鈥淭he new regime you install has its own interests,鈥� Goemans says.

鈥淭hey don鈥檛 necessarily align with the interests of the United States, or with democratic reform.鈥�

Why motivation matters鈥攁nd how neighboring Guyana is in play

There are somewhat conflicting statements coming out of Washington as to the motivation for the American intervention.

House Speaker Mike Johnson has as one that aimed 鈥渢o bring justice to a criminal鈥� in Maduro, who was 鈥渄uly indicted under American law.鈥� Energy Secretary Chris Wright has said the United States intends to control the flow of Venezuelan oil into the marketplace.

鈥�If the United States defects from the rules, others will have incentives to defect too. In the long run, that鈥檚 not in America鈥檚 interest.鈥�

Meanwhile, Secretary of State Marco Rubio has laid out a three-step plan that includes the United States stabilizing the country by seizing and selling up to 50 million barrels of oil and ensuring 鈥淎merican, Western, and other companies have access to the Venezuelan market in a way that鈥檚 fair.鈥� He has called the third step 鈥渙ne of transition,鈥� including the integration of opposition political parties.鈥�

Goemans says motivations matter enormously.

It is possible, he says, that different actors inside the US administration are pursuing different goals鈥攆rom energy interests, to immigration enforcement, to regional dominance鈥攚ithout a coherent long-term plan for Venezuela itself.

鈥淭hat鈥檚 problematic,鈥� he says, 鈥渂ecause it means there鈥檚 no clear, overarching goal. If you don鈥檛 know what comes next, you鈥檙e almost guaranteeing trouble.鈥�

There is one other possible motivation that Goemans sees for the US intervention that he says he has been surprised no one in the Trump administration has invoked: freeing the oil-rich Essequibo region of neighboring Guyana from Venezuelan rule.

Illustrated map showing Venezuela and Guyana with the Guayana Esequiba between.
WHOSE LAND IS IT ANYWAY? According to Goemans, 鈥淕uyana has serious worries about Venezuela鈥� after the latter renewed claims to the oil-rich Essequibo region. (SurinameCentral, CC BY-SA 4.0 via )

鈥淭hat鈥檚 a motivation, which, in my opinion, could have kind of legitimized overthrowing Maduro,鈥� Goemans says.

In 2023, Venezuela to Essequibo, which is nearly the size of Florida and makes up half of Guyana鈥檚 territory. Maduro unveiled new maps displaying it as part of Venezuela, named a military general as its governor, and issued Venezuelan identity cards to people living there.

鈥淕uyana has serious worries about Venezuela,鈥� Goemans says. 鈥淚t鈥檚 a real threat to the sovereignty of Guyana and it鈥檚 surprising that nobody in the Trump administration has invoked that.鈥�

鈥淭here was no claim that this was about restoring democracy,鈥� he continues. 鈥淭hat was never raised as one of the motivations. That should concern people.鈥�

A dangerous precedent for world order

Beyond Venezuela, Goemans warns that forcibly removing heads of state undermines long-standing international norms.

He explains this using a classic political science concept: cooperation only holds if countries believe rules will be enforced over time.

鈥淚f you treat this as a one-shot game that says, 鈥榃e can do this once and nothing follows,鈥� that鈥檚 very dangerous,鈥� he says. 鈥淥ther countries will respond eventually. Maybe not immediately, but the system will unravel.鈥�

He argued that even US allies may feel compelled to push back if territorial integrity and sovereignty no longer carry weight.

鈥淚f the United States defects from the rules, others will have incentives to defect too,鈥� he says. 鈥淚n the long run, that鈥檚 not in America鈥檚 interest.鈥�

Can the US try Maduro?

Another uncertainty is whether US courts can legally prosecute Maduro if he is considered Venezuela鈥檚 legitimate president, which Maduro insists he is despite doubts by many world leaders.

鈥淭his is going to be fought out in court,鈥� Goemans says. 鈥淛udges will have to decide whether he is head of state, and that鈥檚 not a simple legal question.鈥�

Maduro on stage addressing the Venezuelan military.
LAW AND WORLD ORDER: Maduro insists he is Venezuela鈥檚 legitimate president, despite doubts by many world leaders. (Getty Images)

Unlike Panama鈥檚 Manuel Noriega, who was never an elected president but was that country鈥檚 de facto ruler before the United States seized him with an invasion in 1989, Maduro originally came to power through constitutional succession before consolidating his authority through a series of widely condemned elections in 2018 and in 2024.

What are the alternatives?

If US military intervention is unlikely to produce a stable democracy in Venezuela, what could?

Goemans points to historical examples in Eastern Europe and elsewhere, where authoritarian regimes collapsed after mass domestic mobilization, sometimes with outside support and an independent media.

鈥淭he only way the masses can overcome a repressive elite is if they successfully organize,鈥� he says. 鈥淭hat means supporting opposition groups, election monitoring, information access. Not sending troops through jungles to Caracas.鈥�

But he acknowledges how grim that sounds to Venezuelan people suffering now, whether in the country or living abroad.

鈥淚 understand the desperation,鈥� he says. 鈥淧eople have had their lives stolen from them. Of course they want immediate change.鈥�

Still, he warns that celebrating too early could result in disappointment.

鈥淧eople were very happy when Saddam鈥檚 statues came down,鈥� he says, speaking of the former president of Iraq, Saddam Hussein. 鈥淭hen came the question: What comes next?鈥�


Circle crop of a studio portrait of Hein Goemans.
(天美传媒 photo / J. Adam Fenster)

Meet your expert

Hein Goemans

, a political science professor and the director of the 天美传媒鈥檚 , is an expert on international conflict鈥攈ow wars begin and how they end. He听is the author of (Princeton University Press, 2000) and coauthor of 听(Cambridge University Press, 2011).