天美传媒

Skip to content
Society & Culture

Why do people hoard and socialize during a pandemic?

"Many of the items that people are hoarding are 'care' items鈥攄iapers, toilet paper, sanitizer鈥攖hings that enable and represent the ability to give care to others," says Robert Foster, professor of anthropology at the 天美传媒. (Getty Images photo)

What looks like selfishness to one person may be expressions of affection for loved ones to others, says a Rochester anthropologist.

There鈥檚 been quite a public outcry against the mostly young people who have ignored social distance guidelines by gathering in large groups.

But what鈥檚 often seen as selfish behavior can also be an indication of personal attachment鈥攅ven affection鈥攁ccording to , a professor of anthropology at the .

Coronavirus update

The University鈥檚 website is a way to find guidance and critical information during a rapidly changing situation.

COVID-19 symptoms or exposure?

Find out what to do if you or a close contact have symptoms or think you may have been exposed.

鈥淧roximity is usually associated with intimacy, and distance with strangeness,鈥� explains Foster. 鈥淭he public challenge at the moment is that we must learn to express our care and concern by maintaining distance, which is counter-intuitive.鈥�

That鈥檚 hard to do with people who really are our intimates. But even the same people chastised for gathering in groups may go out of their way to keep their distance from elderly relatives, for example, out of genuine concern. 鈥淭he public challenge is to extend that concern to people who are not vulnerable members of their families,鈥� says Foster.

That challenge also comes into play in everyday activities such as grocery shopping. It鈥檚 important not just to maintain distance in stores, but to refrain from hoarding items. Again, hoarding may be viewed as selfish鈥攐r not鈥攄epending on the context.

鈥淢any of the items that people are hoarding are 鈥榗are鈥� items鈥攄iapers, toilet paper, sanitizer鈥攖hings that enable and represent the ability to give care to others,鈥� says Foster. 鈥淲hat might look like selfish behavior is actually motivated by a strong sense of attachment to鈥攅ven love for鈥攖he household and its members.鈥�

That confronts us with the same public challenge: how to extend that sense of care or love to people who are not members of one’s household. 鈥淚n other words,鈥� says Foster, 鈥渉ow do we get people not to take twenty 24-packs of toilet paper, so that others can buy enough to care for their own households?鈥�

Foster likens the current situation to the construction of family bomb shelters in the early 1960s, particularly during the Cuban Missile Crisis. He recalls reading about a child who was upset that his own parents, unlike their neighbors, refused to build a bomb shelter. The child interpreted that refusal as a sign that his parents didn’t love him as much as the neighbors loved their own children.

鈥淭he key here is to recognize that much of the shopping behavior we have witnessed is not about individual consumption,鈥� says Foster. 鈥淚nstead, it鈥檚 a matter of household provisioning by which people demonstrate their connections to each other through giving and receiving care.鈥� The challenge we face, then, is to enlarge the circle of those with whom we exchange care.