What AI can鈥攁nd can鈥檛鈥攖each doctors about connection.
Erika Ramsdale 鈥�21 (MS) is an associate professor of medicine in the Division of Hematology and Oncology at the 听. This content is excerpted from an article of the same title, written by Ramsdale and published in the (vol. 44, no. 28, October 2026).

One day, I met a patient who was never born and who could not die. Her name was Maya. She had metastatic stomach cancer. Her face was a featureless landscape, with none of the quirks of individual embodiment (the mole by your right earlobe, the cloud across your pupil). Maya was a virtual human. She was created to train physicians to have serious illness conversations. I had volunteered to interact with her.
I opened the visit like I normally do in my oncology clinic. 鈥淗ow are you feeling today?鈥�
鈥淕reat!鈥� she chirped. 鈥淗ow are you doing? What is new with you?鈥�
I smiled. 鈥淚 am doing OK. I鈥檓 glad to hear you are feeling well. Let鈥檚 talk about how your last chemotherapy went.鈥�
She frowned a little, or I think she did. Her voice was gregarious and crisp, with infomercial inflection. 鈥淏ut I really want to know what is going on with you! Let鈥檚 talk about your life.鈥�
I glanced at the student who was walking me through the software demonstration. He mumbled something about 鈥渞etraining the model鈥� and 鈥渦nexpected behavior.鈥�
I swiveled my focus back to the two-dimensional, uncannily still face and upper torso sitting in the exact middle of a nondescript rectangle. I could not tell if she was wringing her hands or sitting on the edge of her seat. Were her fingernails painted or chewed and ragged? Perhaps she wore a plain wedding band on her left hand or a set of brass knuckles. I had no way to read what she might need from this interaction and from me. No way, that is, except for ignoring unexpected answers and repeating myself, recombining words until I received clear information back.
Systematically tweaking a request to get the desired output is known as prompt engineering when working with AI language models, and it is an essential skill in working with these machines. When working with patients, ignoring their answers (no matter how unexpected) and repeating questions at them is bad bedside manner. Eliciting information from people requires delicate work, not an engineering approach. 鈥�
鈥淭o learn how to care for people, we should start and end where we always have: with the person in front of us.鈥�
Another fundamental belief has emerged from my work with patients: Our voice and our care are embodied. It is not just the words that matter or the mechanics of them, but the bodies inhabiting the space, the semiotic extravaganza of them. The beads of sweat on the bridge of a nose. The pause, the looking up and to the left, the hitch in the throat. It is bodies that act, and act on us, creating and reinforcing human connection. I walk into the clinic room, I squeeze your hand, I鈥痵mell the scent of the detergent you use, and I remember that your grandson鈥檚 high school graduation is coming up soon. 鈥淲hat do you hope for?鈥� I asked when you were diagnosed with stomach cancer. You did not hesitate. 鈥淚 want to see my grandson graduate high school. I鈥檒l do whatever it takes.鈥� 鈥�
After I closed Maya鈥檚 rectangle, the software created a report grading me on various aspects of the interaction. It also graded me on my empathy, giving me very low marks. It suggested how to improve, by saying things such as, 鈥淭hat sounds very difficult鈥� or 鈥淚 am sorry you are experiencing this.鈥� Within this framework, empathy itself is flattened to call-and-response, a set of platitudes, an algorithm. It is true that these small scripts can help patients feel heard and understood. AI models are often rated higher in empathy than human clinicians. They can consistently deploy rote phrases and mirroring that sound empathic, and they have no bodies or internal states to interfere with this. They do not experience hunger, irritation, the time pressure of a full waiting room, or any of the thousands of frictions that complicate real communication. 鈥� Machines do not teach humans to be more human, and when given the choice, patients prioritize human connection over empathic phrasing. The art may start with a script, but it does not end there. 鈥�
To learn how to care for people, we should start and end where we always have: with the person in front of us. At your next appointment, I ask you about your grandson鈥檚 graduation. Your face breaks open, smiling, and you say, 鈥淚t was a perfect day. I felt well, and I could enjoy it. I wasn鈥檛 even too tired.鈥� You add, wryly, 鈥淵ou can just chuck me in the ravine now!鈥� I wonder what Maya would want me to say to this. It must be hard for you, thinking about being flung into a ravine. Instead, I laugh. We both do. I respond, 鈥淲ell, I took an oath not to throw people in ravines. So here we are. What鈥檚 next?鈥� And you tell me.
This story appears in the fall 2026 issue of Rochester Review, the magazine of the .听
