ÌìÃÀ´«Ã½

Skip to content
Society & Culture

Why ‘playing hard to get’ may actually work

In the Andy Griffith Show episode "Opie's Girlfriend," which aired in 1966, Opie (Ron Howard) goes all out in trying to attract Cynthia (Mary Ann Durkin). According to new research, he may have been better off "playing hard to get." (/Getty Images/Michael Ochs Archives)

Playing hard to get may increase romantic attraction by making a potential partner seem more desirable, according to research from the ÌìÃÀ´«Ã½ and its collaborators.

What to know about playing hard to get

  • Playing hard to get can increase romantic and sexual attraction. In three studies, researchers found that people perceived potential partners who were harder to attract as more desirable.
  • Being selective can make someone seem more valuable as a romantic partner. Participants rated people who appeared more selective about whom they dated as having higher “mate value,â€� a psychological term for perceived desirability.
  • Putting more effort into pursuing someone can increase attraction. Participants who worked harder to attract a potential partner perceived that person as more desirable and were more motivated to see them again.
  • Playing too hard to get can backfire. The strategy may be effective when romantic interest is apparent and a relationship seems possible, but appearing disinterested or arrogant can discourage potential partners.

We tend to like people who like us—a basic human trait that psychologists have termed “reciprocity of attraction.� This principle generally works well to start relationships because it reduces the likelihood of rejection. Yet, making the chase harder also has its advantages. So which one is the better strategy?

A pair of researchers from the and the Israeli-basedÌý have spent the last few years studying the dynamics of human sexual attraction. In a 2019 study, they found that when people feel greater certainty that a prospective romantic partner reciprocates their interest, they will put more effort into seeing that person again. Furthermore, they will even rate the possible date as more sexually attractive than they would if they were less certain about the prospective date’s romantic intentions.

In that study, whether participants felt certain or uncertain about a prospective mate’s interest hinged on whether or not they received a follow-up message from their designated chat partner (who, in reality, was a study insider).

But in published this spring in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, the team now examined the effects playing hard to get, a mating strategy that is likely to instillÌýa certain degree of uncertainty.

The researchers discovered that making the chase harder increased a potential mate’s desirability.

“Playing hard to get makes it seem as if you are more in demand—we call that having higher mate value,� says , a professor of psychology and Dean’s Professor in Arts, Sciences & Engineering at Rochester.

“People who are too easy to attract may be perceived as more desperate,â€� says coauthor , a social psychologist and associate professor of psychology at the IDC Herzliya. “That makes them seem less valuable and appealing—than those who do not make their romantic interest apparent right away.â€�Ìý

“If playing hard to get makes you seem disinterested or arrogant, it will backfire.�

Birnbaum and Reis have collaborated for decades, ever since Birnbaum was a postdoctoral fellow in psychology at Rochester in 1998–99. While playing hard to get is a common strategy used to attract mates, Birnbaum and Reis found that past research has been unclear about whether, and if so, why this strategy works—questions they sought to address in the latest study.Ìý

The duo tested the hard-to-get tactic across three interrelated studies. Participants interacted with what they believed to be another research participant of the opposite sex, but who was in reality an insider—a member of the research team. In each instance, participants rated the extent to which they felt the insider was hard to get, their perceptions of the insider’s mate value (e.g., “I perceive the other participant as a valued mate�), and their desire to engage in various sexual activities with the insider.

The duo tested the hard-to-get tactic across three interrelated studies. Participants interacted with what they believed to be another research participant of the opposite sex, but who was in reality an insider—a member of the research team.

In each instance, participants rated the extent to which they felt the insider was hard to get, their perceptions of the insider’s mate value (e.g., “I perceive the other participant as a valued mate�), and their desire to engage in various sexual activities with the insider.

Across the three studies, the researchers found that people who perceived a potential partner as harder to attract also viewed that person as more desirable and were more motivated to pursue them.

“We all want to date people with higher mate value,� says Reis. “We’re trying to make the best deal we can.�

Of course, some are reluctant to employ this scarcity strategy, worrying that it’ll backfire and drive prospective partners away out of fear of being rejected.

The research was supported by the Israel Science Foundation and the Binational Science Foundation.