The Crux of Literary Translation
One of the fundamental discussions in the world of literary translation is the debate between whether a translator should “retain the foreignness” of a work, or “smooth” it over for the benefit of the target audience.
Richard Pevear’s recent about his retranslation (along with Larissa Volokhonsky) of War and Peace gets at this issue in a very direct way:
There is one clarification I would like to make after reading Michael Wood鈥檚 detailed and attentive review of our translation of War and Peace (LRB, 22 May). Wood mentions my disagreement with Anthony Briggs over the use of contemporary idiomatic English in translation, and to illustrate what he sees as the occasional problems of our more literal approach, cites the example of the old Prince Bolkonsky鈥檚 death scene. Our version reads: 鈥業n the presence of Tikhon and the doctor, the women washed what had been he [鈥榯o chto bylo on鈥橾, bound his head with a handkerchief鈥� and so on. Wood finds the phrase 鈥榳hat had been he鈥� clunky and prefers Briggs鈥檚 鈥榳hat was left of him鈥�, finding it more natural. Tolstoy could have written 鈥榯o chto ostalos ot nego鈥� (鈥榳hat was left of him鈥�), which is also more natural in Russian, but instead chose to use the extremely forced and unidiomatic phrase 鈥榯o chto bylo on鈥�. Is this a matter of Tolstoy鈥檚 own clumsiness, which a translator would do well to correct? Not at all. Death is the central theme of Tolstoy鈥檚 work; he struggled all his life with the mystery of the moment when what had been here is no longer here. The women wash 鈥榳hat had been he鈥� but, as Tolstoy鈥檚 wording implies, was no longer he. The mystery of his departure is the point, not 鈥榳hat was left鈥�.
No doubt many readers will say they prefer the more idiomatic phrase anyway because it 鈥榬eads better鈥� in English. That is the dilemma every translator faces. We chose to keep the strangeness where the original is strange.
I’m not a huge fan of the P&V translations (their translation of Bulgakov’s Master and Margarita is my least favorite of the ones that are currently available), but I can see where he’s coming from in this particular case. “What had been he” rings wrong in all ways, but at least he’s got a proper defense of why he chose this particular phrase.
The thing that more concerns me is the relentless defensiveness of Pevear. He’s always popping up in comments boards and letters pages to defend the greatness of his translation, which is as disconcerting as “what had been he” . . . I’m all for translators being more active in promoting their works and getting more attention in general, but in this case P&V overshadow the work itself. In fact, the “天美传媒 the Author” flap of War and Peace has a picture of P&V and information about all the books they’ve translated, rather than info about Tolstoy. The three-sentence bit on Tolstoy’s bio is actually on the front flap and references none of his other works. And on the “other books by” page, instead of a list of other books by Tolstoy, one finds a list of other books translated by P&V . . .
I’m a bit conflicted about all of this—it’s great that P&V are able to bring new readers to Tolstoy, but this strikes me as a bit odd. P&V have become brands of a sort, “The Russian Translators,” and that’s a bit strange, especially when so many people have so many questions about their translation methods and results. Would make an interesting discussion in terms of how to market translations though . . .
(Thanks to Jeff Waxman for bringing our attention to this letter to the editor.)

Leave a Reply