天美传媒

logo

The Ninth

English-language readers have been enthusiastic about the excellent, albeit sinister, works of fiction by Hungarian writers like Nobel-Winner Imre Kert茅sz, Best Translated Book Award Winner Attila Bartis, and the wonderful P茅ter Esterh谩zy. We鈥檝e been enthusiastic about being disturbed and moved, subjected to nightmare scenes and violent sex, and, ultimately, awed by the mastery these writers鈥攁nd others鈥攈ave over language, such mastery that it transcends the language itself and becomes apparent even in translation. Though by most accounts Ferenc Barn谩s is of the same dark mold, his novel, The Ninth, translated by Paul Olchv谩ry, is a testament to the still-unplumbed depths of contemporary Hungarian literature, and a departure from the alienated fever dreams and horrors to which we鈥檝e grown so accustomed to reading.

Set in Communist Hungary, Barn谩s鈥檚 novel is the story of a nine-year-old child, the ninth child of Hungarian Catholics eking out a miserable living in the small northern town of Pom谩z. Bordering on the stream-of-conscious, The Ninth deals with life under the soft Communist rule of the late 1960鈥檚, but from the point of view of a child with no basis for comparison. The picture we gain from our young narrator is uncomplicated by subtlety, politics, morality, and without the self-conscious morbidity and sexuality found in so many adult narrators. He鈥檚 an observer.

A lack of morbidity hardly means a lack of misery. Here, it’s unconscious, but this child is also disturbingly, accurately, affectless鈥攖oo often in literature, we attribute too much to the too young. Our pathetic unnamed protagonist observes the realities of his own family鈥檚 survival, of his father鈥檚 obsessive small-time industry, his mother鈥檚 fervent religiosity, the difficulties of his siblings, and the cruelties and indignities of life in poverty: His mother and oldest siblings go to factory jobs early in the morning and return late at night; his father wakes the 鈥淟ittle Ones鈥� early to do their part in preparing rosaries and other knickknacks for sale to churches; several of them suffer from some inability to speak or read well and some combination of headaches and faintness; and, of course, he鈥檚 preoccupied with having that eternal symbol of well-being, the full belly:

During the first break of the day I go to the john out in the schoolyard . . . That鈥檚 where I inspect my belly, too, but only if I鈥檓 alone. I pull up my shirt, let loose my muscles, and check to see how much my belly sticks out. In the morning it sticks out a lot.

But his lack of affect! This boy has urges鈥攕ometimes he steals鈥攁nd he observes, but he never experiences anger, only a cold acceptance of his lot in life, of the kicks and shoves of his classmates:

. . . Moln谩r was waiting by the movie theatre. At first I thought he wanted to do the same thing, but I was wrong: he only beat me up . . . I didn鈥檛 really feel the blows, maybe because the whole time I was thinking I鈥檇 been through this before . . .

At nine years of age, Barnas鈥檚 character already knows about survival and necessity. When he and some of his brothers begin working as altar boys during local funerals, he notes, 鈥淭he more people who die in our village, the better for us.鈥� Though he鈥檚 reasonably well cared for, he鈥檚 poor and well-informed about the realities of life. His father is instructive and poverty itself teaches lessons that children can learn quickly. This book is not one that will make waves. It doesn鈥檛 startle or shock, doesn鈥檛 attack the reader or soothe him. This book is notable for the stunning restraint shown, the artfulness with which Barn谩s and Olchv谩ry approached such a delicate task, the translation of child鈥檚 voice. And it鈥檚 notable, too, for its quiet success.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam.