Towards New Ways of Reading
Bonjour 脿 tous! Chad Post has asked me to take some time off from designing my 鈥淕oogle Translate is People!鈥� t-shirts (hint: the words are superimposed over a horrified and battered ) and cover for him this week. I am delighted and honored to be guest blogging at “the threep.” I think this officially means I鈥檓 cool now.
This summer, will feature my translation of French fabulist Georges-Olivier Ch芒teaureynaud鈥檚 鈥淎nother Story.鈥� At the recent AWP I had a fascinating chat about the piece with editor Jeanne Leiby that touched on readers鈥� expectations for translated fiction.
鈥淲e deliberated a long time over this one,鈥� she confided. 鈥淲e liked so much of it enough that if it鈥檇 been a piece by an American author we might have requested rewrites. Since it was a translation, that wasn鈥檛 a possibility.鈥�
鈥淎nother Story,鈥� which closes the Ch芒teaureynaud collection , can be read as a meditation on storytelling: specifically, the wherefore of employing the fantastical elements that are Ch芒teaureynaud鈥檚 stock-in-trade. The question Todorov identified as central to the fantastical genre鈥攊s the impossible real or just in the character鈥檚 head?鈥攊s nested in a metafictional layer, as the story is narrated by a French fantastical writer, the guest of a billionaire on an island that, as Brian Evenson remarks, 鈥渟eems half-built from The Tempest and half from Alfredo Bioy-Casares鈥檚 The Invention of Morel.鈥� What reservations had the editors had about the piece?
鈥淲ell, we thought it was predictable at first. But instead it taught us to change how we read.鈥� It was a reaction to the author鈥檚 work I鈥檇 gotten in rejection slips before. Jeanne went on to say that having the same reaction to a collection of Herta M眉ller鈥檚 stories had made her realize she was perhaps reading foreign stories against the expectations and fulfillments to which American stories had accustomed us.
鈥淧art of the point of publishing translations,鈥� she concluded, 鈥渋s to expose readers to new and alternative narrative forms.鈥�
This brings up all sorts of interesting issues. Storytelling shares features with other technologies: it has its pure mechanics, and can date in ways literature, generally said not to progress unidirectionally, doesn鈥檛. The manipulation of surprise is mostly a technical problem. (If conjecture were to masquerade as generalization, I might say it鈥檚 one that delights every American鈥檚 inner engineer and pragmatist, our homo faber hearts.) Surprise is surely one of narrative鈥檚 virtues, but do Americans overlook, in its favor, other narrative rewards and satisfactions, other priorities and uses? Pop and pulp especially, by standardizing story forms and making, so to speak, formula racers鈥攕leek, streamlined thrill machines capable of hugging hairpin plot reversals and sudden narrative curves鈥攈ave made us canny consumers of plot.
We can ask of a piece, 鈥淒oes this satisfy me in the ways I have come to expect to be satisfied?鈥� or we can assume it has succeeded on its own terms, and then expand our ideas of the possible by trying to define those terms. This is a challenge reading translations sets before us, but I might extend the argument to any kind of fiction you’re not used to. Readers schooled in contemporary American realism may have difficulty with their first forays into fabulist fiction, where the unreal is often left unresolved, a wound in our consensual reality that the story鈥檚 end makes no attempt to close. In approaching any unfamiliar literature, there鈥檚 a learning curve, a disorienting period during which the standards and practices of what you鈥檝e come to take as quality are flouted or ignored.
, by the way, has a great issue out right now with, among other gems, Soren Gauger’s translation of a Witold Gombrowicz excerpt on palant, a Polish ancestor of baseball, that all-American sport and the issue’s theme. Jeanne Leiby has asked me to put out the word that she is looking for translations. Translators, send in your best!

Leave a Reply