Latest Review: "The Deleted World" by Tomas Transtr枚mer
The latest review to our Reviews Section is a piece by Tim Nassau on Tomas Transtr枚mer鈥檚 The Deleted World, which is available from .
This book promises to be an interesting read. Take a look at Tim’s review to see why:
Swedish poet Tomas Transtr枚mer鈥檚 winning the Nobel Prize brought to light a rare bit of translation gossip: that there鈥檚 bad blood between a few of his translators. And as there should be鈥攁 lot of people suddenly want to buy Transtr枚mer鈥檚 poetry; of the five plus out there, which book are you going to get? The Deleted World, Scottish poet Robin Robertson鈥檚 鈥渧ersions鈥� of Transtr枚mer鈥檚 poems (Robertson doesn鈥檛 like to call them 鈥渢ranslations鈥�), is the controversial one. Its first American publication at the end of last year, half a decade after it originally appeared from Enitharmon Press in Britain, drew new attention to the paper war abroad. In the introduction to the slim volume of fifteen poems from across Transtr枚mer鈥檚 career, Robertson makes it clear, 鈥淭he free versions in The Deleted World were never intended as literal translations.鈥� Not free enough for some. As David Orr chronicled in March in the New York Times Book Review, Robin Fulton, also a Scottish poet-translator of Transtr枚mer, and who does speak Swedish, 鈥渁ccused Robertson (who doesn鈥檛 speak Swedish) of borrowing from his more faithful versions while inserting superfluous bits of Robertson鈥檚 own creation 鈥� in essence, creating poems that are neither accurate translations nor interesting departures.鈥� Robertson has barbs of his own: in reference to other Transtr枚mer collections, he dubs Samuel Charter鈥檚 Baltics a 鈥済ood reading鈥� and Robert Bly鈥檚 The Half-Finished Heaven 鈥渁 strong American selection,鈥� while Fulton鈥檚 Collected Poems is a delightfully back-handed 鈥渦seful.鈥� Good for a gloss, but get your poetry elsewhere.
Click here to read the entire review.

Leave a Reply