A Musical Hell
The best way to review Alejandra Pizarnik鈥檚 slim collection, A Musical Hell, published by New Directions as part of their Poetry Pamphlet series, is to begin by stating that it is poetry with a capital P: serious, dense, and, some might say, difficult. Take from that what you will, but I鈥檓 going to follow an idea from Julio Cort谩zar who, in a letter to Pizarnik (reprinted as a preface to this collection), wrote: 鈥淵ou鈥檝e heard of this reviewing method where you page through a book and cite various verses and passages, then make some comment to praise or shoot it down? I don鈥檛 care for this sort of thing.鈥� Okay, point taken, Sr. Cort谩zar. I鈥檓 going to avoid that kind of review this time and try to capture instead the impression of Pizarnik鈥檚 art, a truly foolish endeavor on my part but here goes:
The poems are not formal, though they are earnest, surreal, indebted to artistic traditions that broke with tradition, which was quite a thing in 1971 (when the poems were first published in their native Spanish) I am sure, but in 2014 I must admit that the effect is diminished. Poets have been liberated by the likes of Pizarnik and her forbearers Vallejo, Lorca, Desnos鈥攔eally most post Victorians you can think of. Subsequently, it seems that the most radical thing to do in the 21st century is to turn away from this sort of free verse.
This is not to say that Pizarnik鈥檚 poems are failures. By no means! The work is interesting, often striking. In fact, with full apology to the ghost of Cort谩zar, I鈥檓 going to share a bit that I rather liked:
THAT WORD THAT HEALS
While waiting for a world to be unearthed by language, some one is singing about the place where silence is formed. Later it鈥檒l be shown that the display of fury is not what makes the sea鈥攐r the world鈥攅xist. In the same way, each word says what it says鈥攁nd beyond that, something more and something else.
Okay, class: do you get this? No? Not to worry鈥攜ou鈥檙e not on this earth to understand everything. And that鈥檚 just fine. I choose this poem partially because I like it but more because it is emblematic of the collection; it is not what anyone expects when they encounter a poem (which a lot of readers and critics of poetry have come to expect). And it contains the word 鈥渟ilence,鈥� a word that seems to appear on every other page. Despite the suggestion of the title, there鈥檚 more silence than music, or more concern with silence, more that seems to come from silence than from anywhere else. Which may be the key to unlocking these rather elusive poems, though, frankly, I鈥檓 tired of unlocking elusive poetry. I don鈥檛 need to follow every poem out there; I鈥檓 happy if a poem can bring me to a different place than my linear life can provide, which is exactly what Pizarnik鈥檚 poems do. But I鈥檒l also admit that I didn鈥檛 stay in that grand other place for very long. And not every poem in the slim collection (48 pages in this bilingual edition) brought me anywhere but to the next page in search of something more substantial.
I have the suspicion that had Pizarnik not killed herself at the age of 36 her work might have matured into something more dynamic. The roots of it are present. There鈥檚 invention, bravery, experimentation, but also a note of sadness that sometimes feels callow. Despite this, I must admit to spending quite some time marveling over:
something inside me won鈥檛 give in to the avalanche of ash that can sweep through my insides with her who is me, with myself who is she and is I, unspeakingly different from her.
The nice bits like this ensure that I鈥檒l come back to this volume again and will likely find some other joys along the way. This is often the best we can ask from poets: the desire for rereading and renewed surprise. Pizarnik鈥檚 work is surely no exception.

Leave a Reply