天美传媒

logo

South Korea vs. Spain [Women's World Cup of Literature: First Round]

This match was judged by Mythili Rao, producer for at WNYC.

For more information on the Women’s World Cup of Literature, click here or here. Also, be sure to follow our and like our And check back here daily!

What a brutal match. These two novels hold nothing back. Read in succession, it鈥檚 hard to take in their fight for narrative supremacy without flinching. These are books about the hard truths of life we don鈥檛 wish to discover鈥攂ut are nonetheless powerless to shield ourselves from.

**

First: South Korea鈥檚 effort. It鈥檚 easy to underestimate Bae Suah鈥檚 Nowhere to Be Found. It鈥檚 a slight volume鈥攔oughly as tall and wide as my outstretched hand and only 103 pages long. But the anguish and desperation of those pages lingered in my mind long after I finished reading. The novel follows an unnamed young woman who, when the story opens in 1988, is employed as a temp worker in a dead-end clerical position at the university. Despite her college credentials, it鈥檚 the best job she can get. It鈥檚 better than her second job, serving food, mopping floors, and washing dishes at a restaurant behind the Plaza Hotel; and it鈥檚 much better than the factory job she works screwing caps of dye onto tubes during the university鈥檚 summer break. In any case, father has been imprisoned and her mother drinks too much to hold a job, so the important thing is simply that she work. And work.

While her serious older brother scrimps and saves to make the journey to Japan (where he plans to work for a janitorial service cleaning sewers) and her bright little sister daydreams of completely reinventing herself as a lesbian, Nowhere鈥檚 narrator drifts from job to job in a state of exhaustion. Between shifts, she goes to see her boyfriend Cheolsu. His flat aspect perfectly complements her own numbness:

He just looked blank sometimes. While everyone else was tormented by a restless anxiety, like the dizziness you feel on a spring day, which made them question what they were doing with their lives, Cheolsu was yawning and working on a crossword puzzle. He knew how to accept the tedium without the ennui.

The dramatic heart of this book is built around an unforgivably frigid winter day when the narrator goes to visit Cheolsu on the army base where he鈥檚 completing service. After riding bus to the subway and then another subway to another bus, she鈥檚 told Cheolsu has left the base for training exercise. So she heads back out into the cold on another bus, carrying a bag of chicken Cheolsu鈥檚 nosy mother has entrusted her to deliver to her son. He鈥檚 not there. When she at last finds Cheolsu鈥攂ack in at the headquarters she first visited鈥攈e can鈥檛 understand why she鈥檚 so delayed. The visit ends disastrously.

The narration fast-forwards a decade from there. There鈥檚 a parade of other jobs, and a smattering of new coworkers, acquaintances, and would-be lovers鈥攂ut it鈥檚 as though everything began and ended in 1988. The narrator鈥檚 feeling of dislocation and hopelessness persists and softly, steadily, deepens through the book鈥檚 haunting close. In Sora Kim-Russell鈥檚 translation, Suah鈥檚 prose is cold and acrid. “Time pushes away that which is intended, rejects that which is rejected, forgets that which is sung about, and is filled with that which it turns its eyes from, such as the white hairs of a loved one,” the narrator concludes. When I emerged from the subway after reading Nowhere鈥檚 final page, it was a 70 degree June day but an icy chill ran through my heart.

**

Enter Spain. The Happy City takes a no less deadly but measurably more complex approach. Elvira Navarro鈥檚 novel, set in Madrid, is divided into two parts. The first opens, similarly, with a young man trapped by economic circumstances beyond his control. Chi-Huei spends his early days with his aunt in China; when as an elementary-schooler he鈥檚 finally reunited with his immediate family in Spain, he鈥檚 suspicious of these strangers. As he grows, his feelings toward his family only become complicated. His mother and grandfather run a restaurant that鈥檚 supposed to ensure their future; broken by his time in a Chinese prison, Chi-Huei鈥檚 father does his best to simply comply with his headstrong wife and father鈥檚 wishes. For his part, Chi-Huei is trapped by the weight of familial duty. After Navarro describes the intimate contours of a recurring argument between Chi-Heui and his mother, she leaves the young protagonist with a bleak discovery:

Every day of his life since had arrived had been a hymn to work, to money, to efficiency鈥攁 hymn he had to sing through his excellent grades at school and his help in the kitchen and the aspirations he was required to have for the future. And all as thanks for what they earned him in good faith and with all their love, believing that this and this alone was their duty, the restaurant-rotisserie in which they all worked for aspirations that were not his own and that, to his utter disgust, were quite the opposite, though he wasn鈥檛 able to specify what this opposite was.

The second part of The Happy City follows one of Chi-Huei鈥檚 neighborhood friends, a precocious, secretive girl named Sara who becomes fascinated by a homeless man she encounters on the street. They have something powerful in common: Her imagination, like his, rejects boundaries. Sara鈥檚 parents grow alarmed when the learn of her fascination with this vagrant, but when they ground her, she only grows more obsessed. Nothing in her world is more interesting than this man who lives on the edges of society. Sara and the homeless man begin wordlessly stalking each other; eventually, they strike up a friendship.

It鈥檚 a chaste relationship, but a thoroughly corrupting one, all the same. Sara鈥檚 interest in the homeless man leaves her no time for girlish pursuits. She ignores art classes and is bored by her friends. In The Happy City鈥檚 final scene鈥攁 confrontation between Sara鈥檚 parents and the homeless man in the bar where she has been sneaking afternoon visits over potato chips with him鈥擭avarro again demonstrates an uncanny talent for depicting the layers of tension that build up in family life. As Sara鈥檚 parents enter the bar, “They walk with the full weight of duty upon them, staring hard at the ground, and I suppose they know that I look at them, and that I am terrified.” As Sara鈥檚 father addresses the object of his daughter鈥檚 fascination, she becomes the conversation鈥檚 translator鈥攁nd in doing so, learns something about her own limits.

**

In the end, The Happy City is the winner of this match, 3-2: Nowhere to Be Found鈥檚 best efforts simply couldn鈥檛 match the combined power of Chi-Huei and Sara鈥檚 forceful and sharply aimed narratives. After two beautiful, hard-earned goals per team, in stoppage time, Spain comes through with one more taste of net to win the game.

*

Next up, Spain’s The Happy City will face off against Costa Rica’s Assault on Paradise on Friday, June 26th.

Tomorrow’s match will be judged by Emily Ballaine, and features Germany’s The Hottest Dishes of the Tartar Cuisine by Alina Bronsky up against Thailand’s The Happiness of Kati by Ngarmpun (Jane) Vejjajiva.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam.