Mexico vs. Colombia [Women's World Cup of Literature: Second Round]
This match was judged by Hilary Plum—you can learn more about her writing and editing at her or on Twitter at @ClockrootBooks.
For more information on the Women’s World Cup of Literature, click here or here. Also, be sure to follow our and like our And check back here daily!
The stands are packed on both sides, tension palpable. Mexico鈥檚 entry into this year鈥檚 tournament: Carmen Boullosa鈥檚 Texas: The Great Theft, in Samantha Schnee鈥檚 endlessly sly translation. The novel kicks off in 1859, in a lightly fictionalized version of the Mexican/Texas border, along the Rio Bravo/Rio Grande (depending on where you鈥檙e sitting) and in the twin cities鈥攐r, a Mexican city and a sad Texan excuse for one鈥攐f Matas谩nchez and Bruneville. As the title reminds us and the novel renders in profound detail, this border was drawn in bloodshed and greed: land that is now the state of Texas had first belonged to Mexico, until the Republic of Texas was declared in 1835, for among other reasons the desire to legalize slavery, which was counter to Mexican law. In 1846, Texas joined the U.S., resulting in the war of 1848 that our textbooks know as the Mexican-American War, but which could just be called a U.S. invasion. The US declared a new, more southerly border and land north of it was redirected into American hands鈥攊.e.: stolen. Amid all this, the conflicts with and among the American Indians who were either of or had been relocated to the region continued. If this sounds like a highly complex geopolitical moment in which to set what seems to be a comic novel, you鈥檙e right on.
On one dusty high noon in July in Bruneville, the sheriff/mediocre carpenter of Bruneville insults Don Nepomuceno, son of a prominent Mexican family. Shots are fired, conflict ensues鈥攁n intricate and bloody chain of consequences that our narrator relates with relentless Pynchonian inventiveness. The pace is fast, the tone witty, the speed may be manic but this novel won鈥檛 lose its cool. When I picture this team, its game is soccer as spectacle: moves showy as hell, hairstyles unprecedented. Each short passage in Texas zips into the next, into and out of the lives of a massive cast of characters, ever precise but never not flip. Boullasa鈥檚 form of procedural improvisation is her own, though one thinks too of Aira and Bola帽o: this is art along the high-tide line, style poised, glittering, mid-crash, before exhausting itself. Through the snap and pizazz of the prose, the horrors of this conflict surface; we recall how close we are to the landscape through which Cormac McCarthy鈥檚 Judge raged, the kid with his mindless taste for violence.
Daring, even absurd, Mexico鈥檚 game starts strong: Boullosa鈥檚 nonstop stand-up routines, winking and shapeshifting, take us to halftime with a 2鈥�1 Mexican lead.
We turn then to the Colombian side, where Laura Restrepo鈥檚 Delirium sets a quite different pace: a fluid elegance, a taut lyricism that, we鈥檒l come to see, can both give and take real devastation. The achievements of Restrepo鈥檚 novel鈥攊n Natasha Wimmer鈥檚 translation鈥攁re curiously hard to describe. Its structure is more conventional than Texas鈥檚, without really being conventional; setting the two novels side by side illuminates how Restrepo, too, is playing with genre, though more quietly, so that the reader may almost not notice. The novel is centered on Agustina, a young Colombian woman of upper-class background who is deep in an episode of鈥攐ne could call it delirium, or madness, or mania: in any case she is far from reality. She has spent her life, as we鈥檒l learn, in and out of such episodes, while also believing herself, perhaps being believed by others, to possess visionary powers. Agustina is a sort of absent center, then鈥攅ven though she is one of the novel鈥檚 four narrators, sometimes referring to herself in the first person, sometimes in the third, she also constitutes its vital mystery. What has caused the new and terrible instance of madness in which we discover her in the novel鈥檚 opening scene? This is the question her lover, Aguilar鈥攆ormer professor of literature; current dog-food salesman鈥攕ets out to answer, and which seems to drive the book鈥檚 plot, against the background of 1980s Bogot谩. Aguilar narrates the course of this search, while Agustina鈥檚 sections are set during her childhood, amid the layers of secrecy and oppression that make up her deeply patriarchal family. Agustina鈥檚 grandfather, a German musician obsessed with a young student, occupies the third, haunting narrative strand; the fourth belongs to the propulsive voice of Midas McAlister, Agustina鈥檚 one-time boyfriend and a money launderer who may have just run dangerously afoul of cocaine king Pablo Escobar.
The novel seems, then, to be driven by suspense, infused by noir: a madwoman, a mystery, a detective on the hunt. Yet gradually鈥攏o spoilers here鈥擱estrepo sets aside the simplifying logic of cause and effect and refuses any expectation of easy resolution. One narrator yields to the next, ongoingly, and the instability of each character鈥檚 story reflects a greater instability, a vulnerability intimate to each voice and yet which also belongs to the societal and political moment鈥攄rug traffickers running the nation, guerrillas claiming the highways, bombs detonating downtown鈥攊n which they live. In Wimmer鈥檚 translation, Restrepo鈥檚 syntax is capable of swift architectural feats (you may think of Sebald), suddenly building a world that is half-reality, half-dream, and just as quickly replacing it with another, each creation given life by a vivid sensual glimmer or an offhand flash of her intelligence.
The match is a tense one; both teams play at the top of their games. In the stands you all should have Texas in one hand, Delirium in the other, not able even to pick up your beer till you鈥檝e finished reading. It could go either way, but today, since I鈥檓 the judge, I see Colombia pull away in the game鈥檚 second half, a greater range of moves at its disposal. Texas is so insistently various and vaudevillian that it becomes, in its way, consistent, and loses a bit of momentum: all short fast passes, less chance of the long desperate lob toward goal, of sinking to one鈥檚 knees on the field. We end with a hard-fought 3鈥�2, victory Delirium, in what has surely been another incarnation of the beautiful game.
There we go! All six countries in the quarter- and semi-finals have been decided: Germany, Canada, Cameroon, Australia, Costa Rica, and Colombia. (Very much different from the actual semifinals!)
In terms of pairings, The Hottest Dishes of the Tartar Cuisine gets the top bye and will play the winner of Assault on Paradise vs. Delirium. Oryx & Crake gets the other bye and will face off against the winner of Burial Rites vs. Dark Heart of the Night.
More info soon about these final match-ups. For now, enjoy today’s actual Women’s World Cup quarterfinals . . .

Leave a Reply