天美传媒

logo

Dezafi [Why This Book Should Win]

Check in daily for new Why This Book Should Win posts covering all thirty-five titles .听

P.T. Smith reads, writes, and lives in Vermont.

听by Frank茅tienne, translated from the French by Asselin Charles (Haiti, University of Virginia)

Every year, the BTBA introduces me to books I鈥檇 otherwise completely miss. Whether it鈥檚 because I read it while a judge, because it鈥檚 on the longlist, or because I had the wildly fun advantage of watching them discuss these books and some lodged in my head, like Asselin Charle鈥檚 translation of Frank茅tienne鈥檚 顿茅锄补蹿颈. It was one of a few books rooting to make the longlist despite not having read it. I鈥檝e read Frank茅tienne before, apparently, though I remember nearly nothing of Ready to Burst. Ultravocal has been forthcoming from Archipelago for what seems like years. He鈥檚 the master of Haitian literature. This is a 鈥渮ombie鈥� novel. How can you not root for that?

My copy arrived after the longlist was announced and I dove in. I started it at the same time I was reading another book on the list. 顿茅锄补蹿颈 took over, and that鈥檚 nothing against that unnamed book, but Frank茅tienne just gives us that damn good of a book. And the reason it should win this year is because this is a book only the BTBA could recognize. The entire longlist is a demonstration of how special and full of variety this award is.

Let鈥檚 get the fun, and deceptive, pitch out of the way first. This novel has zombies! It鈥檚 the second book on a BTBA longlist to have zombies! But this was also written in 1975. It鈥檚 not zombies as we know them. It鈥檚 not a literary novel playing with genre tropes to make high-minded people feel comfortable reading about monsters, spaceships, of fantasy kingdoms. The zombies are mostly called zonbis, and they鈥檙e humans who have had their soul stolen by a sorcerer, a Vodou priest. These are Haitian zombies, a parable for poor, abused workers, not George Romero鈥檚 zombies, and certainly nothing like modern and increasingly desperate attempts to add some new spin to zombies. Instead 顿茅锄补蹿颈 is straightforward in that Frank茅tienne has no interest in saying something about the idea of zombies, but instead they are just the perfect and natural fit to the story he鈥檚 telling. These zonbis were made, they exist, they suffer, and they will have their revenge. Despite this warning about 顿茅锄补蹿颈, something remains true: the BTBA has no hesitation paying attention to genre. Last year鈥檚 winner is packed full of sci-fi elements. This is a literary award that embraces genre as an element of literature alongside any style, trick, tool, device, whatever.

What else is it that makes 顿茅锄补蹿颈 deserve to win the title this year? How about that it鈥檚 simultaneously an immensely complex and challenging novel and an engaging read? It鈥檚 got sections in italics, the voice of the zonbis: 鈥淪leep rise look walk eat lick finger blow fall run spend the day hungry. Talk nonsense. Tongue heavy. Tongue shredded in a thousand pieces. Full belly. Twisted guts. Thirsty for water.鈥� The writing here can be fragmented, with partial lines, and spaced across the page, calling to mind poetry. It鈥檚 the collective voice of a people crying out. They want to be heard. They want their souls back. They are also a voice of Haitian tradition, the crossroads, dance. These sections are the most romantic sections, beautiful and fun and strange. They give the zonbis empathy: 鈥淥ur skins are raw. We鈥檙e wounded to our bones.鈥�

The most accessible, straightforward, plot-based narrative is in normal font and tells the story of humans involved with the zonbis, including the sorcerer Sintil and his, uh, daughter/servant/inappropriate relationship, Siltana, and the assistant Zof猫. Siltana will fall in love with one of the zonbis, feed him salt to 鈥減oison鈥� him by making him strong, leading to rebellion. The writing here is still beautiful and wild and unique, but it鈥檚 also where we learn how zonbis are made, the past of the hero zonbi Klodonis, and where the love story between him and Siltana comes through.

The final of the three main types of narrative is in bold text, with slashes to break up lines: 鈥淎ll roads cross in the woods / we rise up early / ass kissing flatterers go a long way / even with a single match you can light a fire /a dandy at the cockfight / gamecocks fight / we break our backs working鈥� These are a bit of everything: the story; the zonbi鈥檚 lives, the cockfighting celebration. They鈥檙e a song of Haiti, the spine of this book.

There are other types of text, and there are section breaks, and a diagram. It鈥檚 complex is what I鈥檓 saying. It鈥檚 intricate in that way where as you read you feel that there are connections everywhere, that the book is overgrown with details and references and ties between sections and lines and ideas and characters and Haitian traditions and history. You feel it. You make out what you can. You don鈥檛 have to see the way the intricacies work to be rewarded with the pleasure they give off. The ride is a the point, and the whole way, you know that you could go deeper, work harder, read closer, reread.

So: genre, joyous, welcoming, yet difficult literature. What else makes for a BTBA book? I鈥檓 no Chad Post, so I haven鈥檛 looked at any numbers, I have no charts, no actual data, but I鈥檓 still going to claim that BTBA is one of the most diverse awards out there, each and every year. In terms of gender of the authors and translators, in terms of language, country of origin, time period, etc., I don鈥檛 believe any award cooks up lists like these ones.

Let鈥檚 make another claim: a fairly diverse award list isn鈥檛 that hard to make. You鈥檙e gonna want to start with the judges. Get some different tastes, different perspectives and backgrounds. Then you鈥檙e gonna want to make the longlist long. It helps. And this isn鈥檛 just throwing a bone out to some books to pad out a list and make it diverse. Naw, not only are all the books on the longlist each year books some judges are passionate about, books that start as longshots that barely made the list often go on to make the short list鈥nd maybe win?

Throughout the year, the judges comment on a spreadsheet where every eligible translation is listed. All books are assigned to a judge to read, workload neatly distributed. This means they are reading books they would never otherwise never come across, they鈥檙e giving it a chance it might not otherwise get. These are the books they want to find. The books that would always get their attention will still get it, but the spreadsheet helps those other books.

The judges want to find books like Dead Rose, 顿茅锄补蹿颈, Congo, Inc., and Slave Old Man. They read and they discuss with intentionality. I watched these discussions happen. There鈥檚 a 颅诲别蝉颈谤别颅 for a diverse list. That desire is there because it鈥檚 how they read. They read with admirable openness, wanting new, wanting challenges. Diverse literature is a leap towards those things. The judges are seeking the best translated books on offer. What that means, they determine, with as many contributing factors as they want. With some judges, the intentionality towards diversity is greater than others. This is a good thing. No one is reading with an agenda, no one is forcing anything, but with honesty, passion, discussion, and varied intentions, a special award list rises.

顿茅锄补蹿颈 is representative of what the BTBA can accomplish. Of the type of book it can help readers uncover. It鈥檚 the first novel written in Krey貌l. It鈥檚 brilliant, both structurally and as a story. The translation is wonderful (there are a few occasions where Charles adds a footnote, explaining a meaning and most of the time it鈥檚 not necessary because he nailed the translation already). It鈥檚 culturally important, both to Haiti and to anyone interested in world literature. Pulling a quote the afterword from Frank茅tienne himself, 鈥�顿茅锄补蹿颈 was first of all for me an aesthetic literary experience at the level of the Creole language. 顿茅锄补蹿颈 is first and foremost the novel of the Haitian language, but as a language is indissolubly linked to the becoming, to the destiny, the lived situation of a people.鈥� He created a work of art in the language of the people, as an aesthetic and a political act. Charles has given that book to us in English. It deserves victory.



One response to “Dezafi [Why This Book Should Win]”

  1. Asselin Charles says:

    Dear Mr. Smith,

    Thank you for this wonderful review of Dezafi. Thank you for rooting for this unusual novel and one of the few works of fiction by a Haitian author to be available in English. Allow me, though, to redresss an important error in the piece: Franketienne wrote Dezafi in Haitian Kreyol, and it is this original work I translated into English. The author did a French translation of his own work, which was published in France; this French version is different from the original in many ways. Anyway, for historical and scholarly purposes, I chose to translate the first published Kreyol novel rather than its French avatar.

    Best regards,

    Asselin Charles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam.