天美传媒

logo

Four Attempts at Approaches [Drawn & Quarterly]

This post comes to you thanks to a few different starting points: a box of translated graphic novels that Drawn & Quarterly sent me a couple of weeks ago, the fact that Janet Hong translated one of them (see last week鈥檚 interview), the fact that I don鈥檛 have time this month to read a ton of novels for these weekly posts, but can totally handle some graphic novels, and because part of my mid-life crisis is a desire to challenge myself and try new things. Like extreme amounts of exercise (at 43 I can still at least be in shape by book-people standards, right?) and trying to write about things I don鈥檛 already know how to write about. Like graphic novels. 听

That said, I am extremely familiar with comic books and graphic novels (total nerd! and yes, of course I saw Avengers: Endgame听and听Captain Marvel听on opening night), but I鈥檝e never tried to write about them听in the ways in which I鈥檝e written about translated fiction. Or even poetry. Although I feel like this post is pretty much in parallel with any of my posts on poetry in the sense that I know from the start that I don鈥檛 have the proper set of terms and concepts to clearly elucidate what makes a poetry collection 鈥済ood鈥� or 鈥済reat鈥� or 鈥渇ine鈥� or 鈥済arbage,鈥� but I have some undefined, general understanding of what I like. 听

Since I haven鈥檛 even had time this week to steal a听fun framework from Sam Miller, I think I鈥檓 going to simply write听something听about each of the four books听I read, namely one aspect of听what makes reading graphic novels interesting.听听

First though, a couple digressions. (Would this even听be听a Three Percent post if I went straight at that听topic?)听听

Over the years, a number of people have asked me听why we don鈥檛 track graphic novels in the Translation Database. The answer is so much more mundane and dumb than hoped for, but also has some odd corollaries. Basically, I can鈥檛 figure out how to get accurate, reliable numbers on manga published here in the U.S.听

When booksellers or translators ask about graphic novels in translation, they usually are thinking of books from Drawn & Quarterly or听Fantagraphics听or First Second or NYRB Comics. They鈥檙e not necessarily thinking about Dragon Ball or Naruto or听Fruits Basket听or听Death Note. All of which have tons of volumes available in English, mostly from presses I don鈥檛 regularly come in contact with.听听听

This is unfortunate, especially since it results in Japanese works in translation being听grossly听under represented in the Translation Database. I have done a lot of research lately to try and capture all the Japanese 鈥渓ight novels鈥� that have come out (again, thank you Rachel听Cordasco), but manga is something I don鈥檛 currently have a hold on.听

And so we end up with a weird situation in which, if I were to add the translated graphic novels that I听do听know about, it鈥檒l ignore far too many Japanese works. OR, I could figure out all the manga, and all the D&Q/Fantagraphics/NYRB Comics books would听be a pretty tiny percentage of all the graphic novels in translation that are available.听Which听actually makes me wonder what the language distribution really听would听be. Like 90% Japanese, 10% French, 10% everything else? I feel like Spanish graphic novels are a bit of a rarity, much less a book from the Balkans or听Baltics.听听

Someday. Someday . . .听听

by Aisha Franz, translated from the German by Nicholas Houde (Germany)

After an unexpected breakup, a young woman named Selma experiences a series of reveries and emotional setbacks. Struggling to relate to her friends and accomplish even the simplest tasks like using a modern laundromat, she sinks deeper into depression. After witnessing another couple break-up and chancing upon the jilted male of the couple, Anders, at his pet store job, Selma realizes that her mysterious neighbor is the woman of that same couple. Her growing despair distances her from from her eager and sympathetic friend. One day, as the mysterious glamorous neighbor is leaving for a business trip, Selma discovers the woman has dropped her key card to her apartment. Selma initially resists but eventually she presses the key to her neighbors lock and enters.

Aisha Franz is a master of portraying feminine loneliness and confusion while keeping her characters tough and real. Her artwork shifts from sparseness to detailed futurist with ease. Her characters fidget and twirl as they zip through a world both foreign and familiar. Base human desires and functions alternate with dreamlike symbolism to create a tension-filled tale of the nightmare that is modern life.

A book with a swear in the title鈥攊s听this听not听the most 鈥渙n brand鈥� graphic novel for me to start with?听听

For this book, which I didn鈥檛 love as much as the others, but did totally enjoy, I want to highlight the idea that听graphic novels are, for me, the Netflix of reading.听Not just in terms of comic books as monthly 鈥渆pisodes鈥� in a particular series, but in the way that you can generally finish a graphic novel in a few sittings, a few hours. In less time than it takes to watch听Avengers: Endgame.听

And as I鈥檝e been reading these books, I鈥檝e gotten so much gratification about being able to听finish things. Contrast this with the鈥攑robably never–别苍诲颈苍驳鈥攑谤辞箩别肠迟s听of reading听Anniversaries听or Marie-Claire Blais. Not that one is 鈥渂etter鈥� than the other, but the process of reading听Against the Day听by Thomas Pynchon over 55 audiobook hours and that of reading听Shit Is Real听over two beers on a Friday night is wildly different.听听听

For me, personally, the main benefits are two-fold: 1) being able to actually听finish听something really triggers that lizard听part of the brain that gives you an adrenaline boost for things like this, and 2) it鈥檚 much easier to think about a narrative鈥檚 鈥渟tructure鈥� if you can digest it in one or two sittings. Trying to keep the shape of听Against the Day听in my mind鈥攐ver the FIVE months I鈥檝e been reading it鈥攊s impossible. I have to keep rereading the synopses of each section, and reading other overviews. And will have to read a lot more after I鈥檝e finished to try and hold all the pieces, all the storylines, all the ideas in mind at once to see how these things fit together.听听

A graphic novel can be like a good TV episode or miniseries in that you actually听can听hold the various parts in mind simultaneously and examine how things fit together or don鈥檛. What the progression is, and听how various scenes mirror or play off of one another.听Narrative structures are fascinating, and it can be hard to pick them out when it takes a month/twenty hours to read a novel.听听

I don鈥檛 have a lot to say about听Shit Is Real听other than it was a bit heartbreaking and surreal and I liked that. And it had a lot of pages like these, which allowed me to be able to read it in one sitting:听

听

And听here鈥檚 a short review from听听that will give you a bit more context:听

We take for granted that visions of tomorrow鈥檚 technology will be drawn with sleek lines and popping sheen, but Aisha Franz鈥檚 Shit Is Real听tacks in the opposite direction, rendering a听Black Mirror鈥�esque world with chalky pencils and deliberately childish figure-work. The result is hypnotically surreal. It provides a backdrop for the achingly relatable tale of Selma, a woman who鈥檚 just been booted by her boyfriend and is trying to sort out her life while navigating a complicated friendship, recurring nightmares, and an awkward romance born in a pet shop. Sexual frustration and crippling loneliness abound, yet the book is curiously buoyant and consistently engaging

听

听by Anneli听Frumark, translated from the听Swedish by Hanna Str枚mberg (Sweden)听

One thing that鈥檚 easy to dismiss鈥攆or non-comics readers鈥攊s the depth and weight of the stories told in graphic novels.听Red Winter听has all the makings of a novella, and was as much of a gut punch as anything else I鈥檝e read this year.听

听The story opens听in media res听and slowly unveils the situation of听Siv听(a married mother of three who lives a not-so-amazing home life with her labor-centric husband) and Ulrik (a young communist she鈥檚 having an affair with, who is trapped by his communist ideals and his age).听It unfolds through a variety of perspectives, each section presenting the viewpoint of one of the characters impacted by this affair:听Siv听and Ulrik, obviously; but also听厂颈惫鈥檚听children, her husband, etc.听听

听Granted, I鈥檓 a sucker for books in which various perspectives clash and bounce off one another, in which you can see the emotional motivations and rights and wrongs of each of the characters. But this affair, the听doomed听(1970s Sweden) aspect of it, the issues with the communist party at that time鈥攖hey all hit home.听听

Although none of them are as impactful as when听厂颈惫鈥檚听daughter is left alone for the night.听This section (54-?) is听a testament to the sort of storytelling you can find in graphic novels that you can鈥檛 exactly replicate in a normal prose book.听There鈥檚 a latent anxiety in the drawings, and in her actions exploring the house, answering the phone (and accidentally covering for her mom), her fears of waking up and finding that her mom听still听isn鈥檛 home . . .听

Again, I don鈥檛 have the right critical vocabulary at hand, but听there鈥檚 something intriguing about how your mind fills in narratives in graphic novels based on existing tropes, subtle artistic elements, and听unadorned dialogue. (By which, I mean, it鈥檚 perfect that graphic novels NEVER have 鈥渉e yelled鈥� or 鈥渉e whimpered鈥� or any other dialogue tag鈥攖he reader听sees听those tags听and听knows听how the lines are being spoken.)听听

That same principle can be extended much more broadly though, to more complicated emotions and reactions.听听

And there is something compelling about听allowing the reader to fill things in . . . I鈥檝e always been a fan of the Cortazar/Calvino reader-interaction theories, but听that鈥檚 a bit more limited听with prose than it is in relation to听graphic novels.听听

This was my favorite of the four books in this post. I鈥檓 not 100% sure I know why, but I听really听got into this. Read it in a sitting. Felt things.听And enjoyed the cartooning and color palate:听

听

听

by J茅r么me Ruillier, translated from the French by Helge Dascher (Madagascar)听

Speaking of the art, let鈥檚 talk about听The Strange, a graphic novel that鈥檚听likely going to get the majority of its attention because of its status as an allegory about immigration (and on that level, it听is听horrifying and unnerving), but for which the art does so much heavy lifting.听听听

I hate talking animals in fiction. Drives me absolutely insane, since the rules about what the animal knows/doesn鈥檛 know (aka how much its simply a human in polar bear form), is usually inconsistent and logically troubling. Which then leads to a lot of questions about听why you chose to use an animal to speak in the first place?听And then shit goes sideways and I can鈥檛 focus on the narrative because I鈥檓 nitpicking over how a dog would or wouldn鈥檛 think and gah. Fuck books with animal narrators.听听

But then we have this.听听

All characters are 鈥渁nimals鈥� in this book, emphasizing how 鈥渢he听stranges鈥� stand out in this society. And for me, for that reason, it works. It鈥檚 not forcing some sort of bullshit logic, or over-explaining an animalistic perspective鈥攊t鈥檚 simply illustrating how society quickly identifies others as听other.听There鈥檚 a lot going on in presenting the protagonist of this graphic novel as a hulking dog, much larger than the duck/cat/mouse people who surround him. Is that realistic, or some sort of prejudice of the mind? 听听

It鈥檚 also worth noting that this book (#19 on Paste Magazine’s ““) is clearly French鈥攁nd loaded with shitty quotes from Marine Le Pen鈥攂ut could so easily apply to parts of 2019 America. Remember when the future was all flying cars and home robots, and not a burning trash fire, no water, and insane amounts of xenophobic hatred? Remember when 鈥渢he future鈥� meant something space age and glorious and not imminent doom? I know this is a digression, but things have gone off-the-rails, and I want to spend some time with some books/movies that present almost idealistic amounts of hope about the future, instead of seeing the next thirty years as the end of everything.听

I mean, not to get too political鈥攁nd this is a Chad W. Post statement, not anything from Open Letter or the 天美传媒鈥攂ut it鈥檚 2019 and we鈥檙e having states ban abortion. We are living in a backward world in which the wrong side is fucking up. Constantly.听

Again: Not to get too political, but instead of wasting your time on this bullshit, why don鈥檛 you try and pass legislation so that my one-year-old son has even a 50% chance of living to the age of 80. Instead of being the worst combination of moralistic, misogynist, xenophobic, pro-Uber-capitalist, and just overall disconnected from people.听听

听/end rant.听

by Ancco, translated from the Korean by Janet Hong (South Korea)

I have听yet to talk about translation at all in this post. (Although, apologies again for a minor political interlude. @ me all you want. I kind of don鈥檛 care anymore.) But given that I talked to Janet already about this book鈥攚hich is great! And violent! And quite complicated in its structure!鈥攖his seems like a good time to highlight a few issues in translating/publishing graphic novels versus doing the same for more conventional novels.听听

One of the big things鈥攆or both translators and publishers鈥攊s lettering. From a very pragmatic perspective, if you already have a book available in Korean, drawn with word bubbles of a particular size,听you would prefer to change as little as possible and just replace the text in the original word bubble with words in a new language.听听

Obviously.听听

But if you鈥檙e going from Korean to English? How easy is that, really? There are a number of languages that require 20% fewer鈥攐r more鈥攚ords when going into English, which is an insane percentage to think about when you鈥檙e talking about fitting these words into a specifically sized bubble.听听

That鈥檚 a logistical issue. One that translators don鈥檛 necessarily have to consider when they鈥檙e translating a novel.听听

Another thing: For the most part, graphic novels are told through dialogue. Which is one of the hardest things for translators to translate. Novels in translation that fail鈥攐r receive 鈥渢oxic鈥� reviews鈥攁re generally those in which the dialogue sounds flat or off or dumb or not native. Sure, every example cited here has some sort of first- or third-person narration, but dialogue still drives the majority of graphic novels. (I think.) And that makes it a trick thing! Get the tone right鈥攊n a predetermined amount of space/words . . .听听

Bad Friends听is phenomenal, by the way. Maybe one day there will be a major听U.S.-based graphic novel award in translation for this book to win. Because it deserves it.听



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam.