Latest Review: "Berlin" by Ale拧 艩teger
The latest addition to our Reviews section is by Vincent Francone on Berlin by Ale拧 艩teger, translated by Brian Henry, Forrest Gander & Alja啪 Kovac and published by Counterpath Press.
Vince has brought up a lot of interesting points in this “review,” and questions the relationship of the reader’s response to a book to the perceived value of a book. I’ve had many similar reading experiences: a book has been, by all logistical elements, a fine book, I can identify it as being well written, can think of a handful of other people who would love it to bits鈥攁nd yet for me it didn’t quite click. But whether or not that’s reason for me to state that a book is lacking in some way… I’m not so sure that’s always the case.
Anyway, here’s the beginning of Vince’s review!:
Randall Jarrell once argued a point that I will now paraphrase and, in doing so, over-simplify: As a culture, we need book criticism, not book reviews. I sort of agree, but let鈥檚 not get into all of that. Having finished Berlin by Ale拧 艩teger, I am reminded of Jarrell鈥檚 idea because I am supposed to be writing a review of Berlin and I realize that I am not 艩teger鈥檚 ideal reader. I came to the book with expectations and am, to be completely honest, disappointed. But so what? A book didn鈥檛 do what I鈥檇 hoped it would do. Does that make it a failure?
Of course not. It makes it a book with a specific vision that seemed well suited to my tastes and interests, even if the execution was different than I鈥檇 imaged. I love books that make interesting use of cities. I love the way G. Cabrera Infante made Havana such a part of his work; I adore how Ciaran Carson writes about his native Belfast; I鈥檓 awed by Faulkner鈥檚 ability to spin gold out of rural Mississippi. The list goes on: Bukowski鈥檚 L.A.; Auster鈥檚 New York; Joyce鈥檚 Dublin. As someone who has spent a lot of effort writing stories and poems about a city I both love and hate, I should have been more receptive to 艩teger鈥檚 book. After all, this is a poet writing in prose about his individual encounters with Berlin. Sounds like my kind of book.
And it is. Sort of. Berlin is a book of quick prose pieces by a Slovenian poet about his time in Berlin. Most of the miniature essays are accompanied by photos, some of which make up the most stunning parts of the book. There are allusions to other great writers who walked the Berlin streets, as well as a humorous exchange with a fellow poet, and tiny details (food, bakeries, the weather) that add up to something indeed, though I will admit that I am not exactly sure what. This is evidence of my response as a reader, not 艩teger鈥檚 failure as a writer, though it makes an objective review difficult.
For the rest of the review and more deep thoughts, go here.

Leave a Reply